The UK’s motor finance industry faces continued uncertainty following the Supreme Court’s recent decision to block a Treasury attempt to intervene in an ongoing car finance scandal. The decision signals potential financial consequences running into billions, impacting both lenders and borrowers alike.
Supreme Court Rejects Treasury Intervention
The UK’s highest court refused the Treasury’s application to intervene in the landmark case surrounding undisclosed commission payments on car loans. The government’s involvement had been widely anticipated as a positive signal for lenders, potentially reducing the billions in compensation claims facing the industry. However, the rejection dashed these hopes, immediately impacting the share prices of major players.
Lloyds Banking Group, parent company of Black Horse vehicle finance, saw its share value drop 3.12%, while Close Brothers—a leading name in the case—experienced a substantial fall of 8.05% following the ruling.
Understanding the Car Finance Scandal
The controversy revolves around the practice of undisclosed commissions in car finance deals. Last October, the Court of Appeal delivered a critical judgement, declaring that any commission not transparently disclosed to customers was unlawful. This ruling paved the way for substantial compensation claims, potentially costing lenders tens of billions of pounds.
Both Close Brothers and FirstRand, the parent company of MotoNovo Finance, are appealing against this significant ruling in the Supreme Court, with the final verdict expected in April 2025. The Supreme Court’s recent decision has amplified the tension surrounding the upcoming appeal, making it one of the most closely watched cases of the year.
If your business buys, sells, repairs or modifies vehicles then Plan Insurance Brokers can source a tailored Motor Trade insurance policy for you. If you have any more questions or would like a quote call our expert team, request a call back or fill in a quote form.
FCA Steps In, Treasury Steps Back
While the Supreme Court has rejected the Treasury’s request to intervene, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has been granted permission to participate actively in the appeal process. The FCA’s role will include submitting written and oral evidence to ensure a balanced and fair resolution.
An FCA spokesperson expressed readiness, stating, “We have been granted permission to intervene in the case and look forward to assisting the court.” The FCA’s involvement is expected to bring regulatory clarity and moderate the final outcomes in terms of compensation amounts.
Industry Response: Concerns and Optimism
Market analysts have described the Supreme Court’s decision as disappointing for investors but not entirely surprising. Gary Greenwood of Shore Capital remarked that the FCA’s involvement might still be a silver lining, especially if its stance aligns closely with the Treasury’s concerns about proportionality in compensation.
Jefferies analysts were pragmatic, highlighting that while the Treasury’s intervention might have comforted the market, its key concerns had already been voiced. The case remains shrouded in uncertainty, keeping investors and industry observers cautious.
Implications for Borrowers and Advisors
For consumers, the outcome of the Supreme Court appeal in April could result in widespread compensation claims, potentially benefiting those affected by undisclosed commissions. For insurance and finance brokers alike, this case underscores the vital importance of transparency in financial transactions. The ruling could shape industry standards for years to come.
As trusted advisors, finance providers must remain vigilant and informed, helping their motor trade clients navigate any changes that emerge from this landmark case. Car traders are heavily reliant on competitive finance making vehicle purchasers affordable. An adverse impact on the
Stay Updated
As developments unfold in the Close Brothers Supreme Court appeal in April 2025: lenders, car dealers, buyers as well as potential claimants will want to stay informed. The final verdict may redefine transparency practices in motor finance as well as lending rates going forward and significantly impact compensation frameworks.
Find out why 96% of our customers have rated us 4 stars or higher, by reading our reviews on Feefo.