The world of car loans just took a serious turn with a major Court of Appeal ruling against lenders MotoNovo Finance and Close Brothers. The case centred around “secret” commission payments on motor finance deals, has the potential to reshape the industry, and has understandably left consumers and lenders alike wondering what happens next.
The Basics of the Motor Finance Scandal
The spotlight has been on the car finance industry for some time, with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) launching an investigation in January 2023 into commission structures. Why? Rising consumer complaints flagged questionable practices in how lenders compensated brokers (the dealers arranging the finance). This review looked at deals going back to April 2007, a broad timeframe for potential mis-selling.
Now, the Court of Appeal has ruled that lenders like Close Brothers and MotoNovo Finance were guilty of a major misstep – paying brokers secret or inadequately disclosed commissions. These commissions, given for arranging finance, were an open secret in the industry. However, the court concluded that consumers weren’t adequately informed about these arrangements, which is a problem when those brokers have a duty to act in the best interests of their customers.
Why “Secret” Commissions Are Causing Such a Stir
The term “secret commissions” may sound dramatic. Still, it essentially refers to payments made by lenders to brokers without clear, upfront disclosure to the customer. In this case, brokers, who were supposed to be impartial advisors, were receiving incentives that could influence their recommendations. The court highlighted a “conflict of interest,” as the brokers had a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of consumers.
In legal terms, the failure to disclose these commissions resulted in a lack of “informed consent” by the customer. The court’s ruling stated that customers would not have reasonably expected such incentives, putting lenders in the hot seat for a potential avalanche of compensation claims.
If your business buys, sells, repairs or modifies vehicles then Plan Insurance Brokers can source a tailored Motor Trade insurance policy for you. If you have any more questions or would like a quote call our expert team, request a call back or fill in a quote form.
Big Financial Fallout for Close Brothers
With this ruling, lenders face the prospect of hefty compensation payments. Close Brothers, for instance, took a big hit in the markets as investors reacted swiftly to the news. Their stock dropped a sharp 24.5%, while Lloyds Banking Group, also heavily invested in the motor finance sector, saw a 7.3% decline.
Close Brothers announced they would temporarily halt all new UK motor finance businesses and may appeal the decision to the Supreme Court. However, they’re not entirely unprepared. In response to this judgement and the potential for further regulatory scrutiny, Close Brothers has taken proactive steps to protect its capital. The company has already sold off its asset management business, boosting its capital position by about £400 million.
The Potential Cost to the Industry
This ruling could have consequences far beyond Close Brothers. The FCA’s review and the recent Court of Appeal decision could open the door to other types of finance arrangements involving discretionary commissions – possibly impacting the entire lending landscape. RBC Capital Markets estimates that consumer compensation across the industry could reach as high as £16 billion, a staggering figure showing how widespread this issue might be.
Stephen Haddrill, director general of the Finance & Leasing Association, said the ruling has implications that “stretch far beyond the motor finance sector.” Analysts are already speculating about broader effects on similar loan arrangements where discretionary commissions are involved, making it clear that this ruling could set a lasting precedent.
What This Means for Consumers
For consumers, this ruling is a victory that highlights their rights in financial transactions. The verdict has already inspired Lloyds to set aside £450 million to potentially compensate motor finance customers, though analysts believe this figure may still fall short. If you bought a car on finance and suspect you were affected, this could be a good time to review your agreements and potentially seek legal advice on how to proceed.
With the FCA actively investigating, the motor finance industry could be in for an extended period of reassessment and possibly restructuring. Ultimately, this ruling and the FCA’s actions underline the importance of transparency in financial products and consumer rights in protecting against potentially biased advice.
Moving Forward
The Close Brothers ruling could serve as a wake-up call for the finance industry, reinforcing the importance of disclosure and consumer protection. And while the outcome of any appeals remains uncertain, it’s clear that this decision has already shaken up the industry, sparking changes that may well outlast the immediate wave of compensation claims.
Whether you’re an industry professional or a consumer, staying informed about the FCA’s review and understanding how it might affect future finance deals is essential. The outcome of these cases could change the rules of the game in motor finance, and possibly other sectors as well.
Find out why 96% of our customers have rated us 4 stars or higher, by reading our reviews on Feefo.