The motor finance industry has come under intense scrutiny in recent years, and the latest review by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) aims to clarify historic car loan commission practices. With FCA Chief Executive Nikhil Rathi at the helm, the investigation reveals issues regarding how car loans were incentivised and whether consumers were treated fairly. This review could have significant implications for anyone who has taken out a car loan in the past.
What’s the FCA Reviewing?
The FCA is focusing on how motor finance companies used discretionary commission arrangements before they were banned in January 2021. These commissions allowed brokers and dealerships to adjust the interest rates on car loans, with higher rates often resulting in bigger commissions for the salespeople. The question now is whether these arrangements led to consumers paying more than they should have without being fully informed.
According to Nikhil Rathi, the FCA has already found “issues” with how these commissions were handled, and the review is working to understand just how widespread the problem was. The findings will determine whether a structured redress scheme, similar to the one put in place for mis-sold Payment Protection Insurance (PPI), is necessary.
What is a Redress Scheme?
If the FCA finds that car loan commission practices misled consumers, a redress scheme could be introduced. This would provide a straightforward, consistent method for affected consumers to seek compensation. While Rathi emphasised that any redress for motor finance issues is unlikely to reach the scale of the PPI scandal, it could still involve significant payouts for customers who overpaid for their car finance deals.
Rathi also highlighted that the FCA’s role is to ensure that consumers are compensated and that the motor finance market continues to function well. Car finance is a critical part of the UK economy, with nearly 80% of households owning a vehicle. Therefore, any action must ensure consumers can still access affordable finance options.
If your business buys, sells, repairs or modifies vehicles then Plan Insurance Brokers can source a tailored Motor Trade insurance policy for you. If you have any more questions or would like a quote call our expert team, request a call back or fill in a quote form.
The Review Timeline and Its Impact
The FCA review was initially expected to conclude sooner, but several factors have caused delays. Many firms involved in motor finance have been slow to provide data that the FCA needs to complete its investigation. Additionally, legal cases regarding motor finance commissions, including a judicial review of one ruling by the Financial Ombudsman Service, have further delayed progress. As a result, the FCA has extended the review into spring 2025.
In a precautionary move, the FCA has also paused complaints about motor finance commissions until December 2025. This allows time to fully assess the scale of the problem and implement any necessary redress scheme. However, Rathi has made it clear that if the FCA can resolve matters sooner, they will.
The Potential Impact on Motor Finance Firms
The FCA’s review is a serious wake-up call for motor finance companies. The FCA has reminded firms of their obligations to maintain adequate financial resources, particularly in light of potential redress liabilities. In a letter earlier this year, the FCA urged firms to avoid making significant financial distributions, such as paying large dividends to shareholders, if they foresee future compensation claims.
Notably, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme does not cover motor finance, meaning customers wouldn’t be protected if a firm collapses. This makes it even more critical for firms to ensure they have enough resources to cover any potential redress payouts.
What’s Next for Consumers?
For car buyers, the FCA’s investigation is a welcome development. Anyone that took out a car loan before 2021, should be keeping an eye on the FCA’s findings. While no formal redress scheme is in place yet, the fact that the FCA is considering one suggests that some customers may have been overcharged.
Rathi’s recent comments have been explicit: the FCA is committed to ensuring a fair outcome for consumers and maintaining a healthy motor finance market. The ongoing review will bring more clarity to a complex situation, and by 2025, we should have a better understanding of what’s in store for the millions of people who rely on motor finance in the UK.
Find out why 96% of our customers have rated us 4 stars or higher, by reading our reviews on Feefo.